Coming in the next few days, I just sent it in to Lew. It's mainly pulled directly from the decade lists with the albums in the same order, but I did make a few corrections of wrong years, and a few minor changes in the order of a couple things.

1956
1 ¦ Elvis Presley - Elvis Presley
2 ¦ Johnny Burnette and the Rock 'n Roll Trio - Johnny Burnette and the Rock 'n Roll Trio
3 ¦ Elvis - Elvis Presley
4 ¦ Bluejean Bop - Gene Vincent and His Blue Caps
5 ¦ The Teenagers Featuring Frankie Lymon - Teenagers
6 ¦ Rock And Rollin' With Fats - Fats Domino
7 ¦ Rock 'n' Roll Stage Show - Bill Haley and His Comets
8 ¦ The Platters - Platters
9 ¦ Johnny Cash With His Hot And Blue Guitar - Johnny Cash
10 ¦ Rock And Roll - Buddy Johnson

1957
1 ¦ The Chirping Crickets - Crickets
2 ¦ Here's Little Richard - Little Richard
3 ¦ After School Session - Chuck Berry
4 ¦ Loving You - Elvis Presley
5 ¦ Dance Album - Carl Perkins
6 ¦ This Is Fats Domino! - Fats Domino
7 ¦ Ricky - Ricky Nelson
8 ¦ Goodnite, It's Time To Go - Spaniels
9 ¦ This Is Fats! - Fats Domino
10 ¦ Here Stands Fats Domino - Fats Domino

1958
1 ¦ Bo Diddley - Bo Diddley
2 ¦ Buddy Holly - Buddy Holly
3 ¦ Little Richard - Little Richard
4 ¦ Jerry Lee Lewis - Jerry Lee Lewis
5 ¦ King Creole - Elvis Presley
6 ¦ The Everly Bothers (They're Off And Rolling) - Everly Brothers
7 ¦ One Dozen Berrys - Chuck Berry
8 ¦ Have Twangy Guitar, Will Travel - Duane Eddy
9 ¦ Oh! Suzy-Q - Dale Hawkins
10 ¦ King Of The Stroll - Chuck Willis

1959
1 ¦ The Paragons Meet The Jesters - Paragons & Jesters
2 ¦ Chuck Berry Is On Top - Chuck Berry
3 ¦ Flamingo Serenade - Flamingos
4 ¦ Go Bo Diddley - Bo Diddley
5 ¦ Ricky Sings Again - Ricky Nelson
6 ¦ Here's Larry Williams - Larry Williams
7 ¦ Look! It's The Moonglows - Moonglows
8 ¦ Ritchie Valens - Ritchie Valens
9 ¦ We Are The Imperials - Little Anthony and the Imperials
10 ¦ The Crazy Cadillacs - Cadillacs

1960
1. Elvis Is Back - Elvis Presley
2. It's Everly Time - Everly Brothers
3. The Buddy Holly Story, Volume 2 - Buddy Holly
4. Walk, Don't Run - Ventures
5. Rockin' At The Hops - Chuck Berry
6. A Date With The Everly Brothers - Everly Brothers
7. Rockin' With Wanda - Wanda Jackson
8. Twist With Chubby Checker - Chubby Checker
9. The Genius Hits The Road - Ray Charles
10. G.I. Blues - Elvis Presley

1961
1. At Last - Etta James
2. Bo Diddley Is A Gunslinger - Bo Diddley
3. Two Steps From The Blues - Bobby "Blue" Bland
4. The Shadows - Shadows
5. Blue Hawaii - Elvis Presley
6. Your Twist Party With The King Of The Twist - Chubby Checker
7. Let's Hide Away and Dance Away With Freddie King - Freddie King
8. Dance 'Til Quarter To Three - Gary U.S. Bonds
9. Hi! We're The Miracles - Miracles
10. Runaround Sue - Dion

1962
1. Modern Sounds In Country And Western Music - Ray Charles
2. Green Onions - Booker T and the MG's
3. Bob Dylan - Bob Dylan
4. Crying - Roy Orbison
5 - Modern Sounds In Country And Western Music Vol. 2 - Ray Charles
6 - Here's The Man - Bobby "Blue" Bland
7 - Surfer's Choice - Dick Dale and the Del-Tones
8 - Baby It's You - Shirelles
9 - Lovers Who Wander - Dion
10 - Sherry & 11 Others - Four Seasons

1963
1. Live At The Apollo - James Brown
2. Please Please Me - Beatles
3. The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan - Bob Dylan
4. With The Beatles - Beatles
5. A Christmas Gift For You - Phil Spector (Various Artists)
6. Night Beat - Sam Cooke
7. Surfin' USA - Beach Boys
8. In Dreams - Roy Orbison
9. The 12 Year Old Genius - Little Stevie Wonder
10. If You Need Me - Solomon Burke

1964
1. A Hard Day's Night - Beatles
2. Live At The Star Club, Hamburg - Jerry Lee Lewis
3. St Louis To Liverpool - Chuck Berry
4. The Times They are A-Changin' - Bob Dylan
5. Beatles For Sale - Beatles
6. Another Side Of Bob Dylan - Bob Dylan
7. Rolling Stones/England's Newest Hit Makers - Rolling Stones
8. Where Did Our Love Go - Supremes
9. Ain't That Good News - Sam Cooke
10. The Animals - Animals

1965
1. Highway 61 Revisited - Bob Dylan
2. Rubber Soul - The Beatles
3. Bringing It All Back Home - Bob Dylan
4. Otis Blue - Otis Redding
5. Mr. Tambourine Man - The Byrds
6. Help! - The Beatles
7. The Who Sings My Generation - The Who
8. The Beach Boys Today! - The Beach Boys
9. Temptations Sing Smokey - The Temptations
10. Going To A Go-Go - Smokey Robinson And The Miracles

1966
1. Pet Sounds - The Beach Boys
2. Revolver - The Beatles
3. Blonde On Blonde - Bob Dylan
4. Face to Face - Kinks
5. Fresh Cream - Cream
6. Freak Out! - Frank Zappa And The Mothers Of Invention
7. Aftermath - The Rolling Stones
8. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme - Simon and Garfunkel
9. If You Can Believe Your Eyes And Ears - The Mama's and Papa's
10. John Mayall & Bluesbreakers-w/E. Clapton - John Mayall/Bluesbreakers

1967
1. Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band - The Beatles
2. Are You Experienced - Jimi Hendrix Experience
3. The Doors - The Doors
4. I Never Loved A Man The Way I Love You - Aretha Franklin
5. Velvet Underground And Nico - Velvet Underground
6. Axis: Bold As Love - Jimi Hendrix Experience
7. Disreali Gears - Cream
8. Surrealistic Pillow - Jefferson Airplane
9. Days Of Future Passed - Moody Blues
10. Magical Mystery Tour - The Beatles

1968
1. The Beatles ("The White Album") - The Beatles
2. Electric Ladyland - Jimi Hendrix Experience
3. Astral Weeks - Van Morrison
4. Beggars Banquet - The Rolling Stones
5. Music From Big Pink - The Band
6. Lady Soul - Aretha Franklin
7. Sweetheart Of The Rodeo - The Byrds
8. Something Else - The Kinks
9. Truth - Jeff Beck
10. Wheels Of Fire - Cream

1969
1. Abbey Road - The Beatles
2. Tommy - The Who
3. Led Zeppelin II - Led Zeppelin
4, Let It Bleed - The Rolling Stones
5. Led Zeppelin I - Led Zeppelin
6. The Band - The Band
7. Stand - Sly And The Family Stone
8. In The Court Of The Crimson King - King Crimson
9. Green River - Creedence Clearwater Revival
10. Crosby Stills and Nash - Crosby, Stills, Nash

The lists are now up:

http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_albums-top-tens-1956-1959.html

http://digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_albums-top-tens-1960-1969.html

How on the earth is Let It Bleed greater than LZ1?

Don't know if Let It Bleed has to be higher, but musical impact would be the reason why it's higher.

It has higher initial popularity as well.

I agree. Zep 1 probably wins overall popularity, but not by very much.

Or by a mammoth amount if you believe the RIAA.

The Let It Bleed certification hasn't been updated since 1989. If it were up to date, I think it would still be well below the Zep level, but we can only have a very rough idea where it would be. So yes, it's a question of how much you weigh incomplete info.

for 1969, wouldn't Willy and the Poor Boys be the better choice for CCR?

LZI has a much bigger musical impact and has garnered a greater critical acclaim. Influence is an easy win for LZI.

Well, according to acclaimedmusic.net (probably the best gauge for acclaim on the net, despite not being perfect), Let It Bleed is far more acclaimed than Led Zeppelin I. LIB is at #36, while LZI is at #108. I don't know about musical impact, but I can see Zep winning that. LZI wins influence too, but I wouldn't say it's an easy win.

LZI isn't as sterling as you're making it out to be

If we're defining musical impact as the contemporaneous appreciation of peers for the work, Let it Bleed certainly wins that.

Influence: LZ1
Musical Impact: Let It Bleed
Popularity: LZ1

I'm not so sure, I think Let It Bleed might be more popular