Brett Alan wrote:
Definitely not going to use the original criteria. I was thinking something along the lines of "Popularity, acclaim, influence, and importance within the country music world." Should acclaim be in there? Not sure.
I'd say popularity, acclaim and influence both in country music circles and in popular music in general. Importance is a vague term and would already be included in these three criteria.
Brett Alan wrote:
My thinking on "Forever And Ever Amen" is that it really heralded a sea change in country music; I know in radio circles for a long time it was the dividing line between what a contemporary country station could and couldn't play. "Make The World Go Away" is similar, in that way; they both rate so high because I think they had a big impact on what records got made and played in their wake. While Johnny Cash is undoubtedly more important than Eddy Arnold and WAY more important than Randy Travis, I'm not sure any one of his records had quite that impact. (Similarly, Willie Nelson and Garth Brooks didn't get into the top ten but will have at least two songs each not far below.)
You're definitely more knowledgeable about country than I am, so I'll believe you that.
Brett Alan wrote:
Which of the really early records are the most important ones? I'm thinking "Blue Yodel #1 (T For Texas)" be the highest--is that right? What would come next?
Don't know what you define as "really early". If '30's count probably "Wildwood Flower" and "Wabash Cannonball". The 1920's songs are in the following order on acclaimedmusic.net:
1. Blue Yodel (T for Texas)
2. Wildwood Flower
3. Sally Gooden (apparently among the earliest country records ever made, there were no commercial country recordings made before 1922)
4. The Little Old Log Cabin in the Lane
5. Keep on the Sunny Side
6. The Prisoner's Song
7. The Coo Coo Bird
8. Pan American Blues
9. Keep My Skillet Good and Greasy
10. Don't Let Your Deal Go Down
11. In the Jailhouse Now
12. Country Blues