Brilliant idea for a list, Dunbrow!
Just a few early thoughts:
Maybe an unpopular opinion but I'm starting to think Vice City and San Andreas should be > IV nowadays though. IV's massive acclaim on release doesn't seem to have lasted as long and Vice City and San Andreas always seem to be the 2 most popular GTA games whenever the discussion of best GTA game comes up.
I definitely think MGS3 should be ahead of MGS4 too and I reckon Peace Walker should probably be the #5 entry over the original Metal Gear.
I'd probably switch the original Final Fantasy with Final Fantasy IV.
Definite debate about the ordering of Twilight Princess, Wind Waker and Majora's Mask for the 4th and 5th spots on the Zelda list, but I'm fine with it any way really.
Not sure about Mario Galaxy over Yoshi's Island. Could go either way that one.
Tbf, you may as well expand the bigger franchises like Mario, Zelda and Final Fantasy to a top 10. Would be awesome.
Other than that looks brilliant! Great stuff.
Here's a Silent Hill one as well.Silent Hill
1. Silent Hill 2
2. Silent Hill
3. Silent Hlll 3
4. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
5. Silent Hill 4: The Room