Once again, if no one has any other comments by 5:00 then that's the list that's going up.

Well then you don't need to comment on the Burzum list at all seeing as you aren't a Burzum fan.

I'd still make a few changes in the top 5. For example Dunkelheit is the most important song from Burzum in the whole. Talking only about metal it looses some arguments going for it, but I still think it's definitely top 3 song.

DSEV only 1 place higher than HLTO also seems a bit wrong.

By saying LW > KttG I didn't mean both of this songs should make top 3 ;)

For me it should look like:

1. JD
2. DH = LW = DSEV
5. KttG

And I wouldn't complain about order of these 3 songs as long as DH would be in the top 3.



Sorry for questioning that minor things, but DDD lists should be perfect, right? I'm open for discussion anyway.

I am not tying three songs together. That would open a Pandora's box of mathematical stupidity for all other lists that would annoy just about everyone involved.

Anyways, with your comments in mind,

1. Jesu Dod (Filosofem)
2. Dunkelheit (Filosofem)
3. Lost Wisdom (Det Som Engtat Var)
4. Key To The Gate (Det Som Engtat Var)
5. Det Som Engtat Var (Hvis Lyset Tar Oss)
6. Hvis Lyset tar Oss (Hvis Lyset Tar Oss)
7. War (Burzum)
8. Erblicket Die Tochter Des Firmaments (Filosofem)
9. My Journey to the Stars (Burzum)
10. Ea, Lord of the Depths (Burzum)


I'll give this one until 9-10 (depending on when I get back from my club tonight).

Considering Hvis is far and away Burzum's most acclaimed album, I don't see how the highest song from that album is only number 5.

Note: I greatly prefer Filosofem.

1. Jesu Dod (Filosofem)
2. Dunkelheit (Filosofem)
3. Det Som Engtat Var (Hvis Lyset Tar Oss)
4. My Journey to the Stars (Burzum)
5. Lost Wisdom (Det Som Engtat Var)
6. Key To The Gate (Det Som Engtat Var)
7. Hvis Lyset tar Oss (Hvis Lyset Tar Oss)
8. War (Burzum)
9. Erblicket Die Tochter Des Firmaments (Filosofem)
10. Ea, Lord of the Depths (Burzum)

This was composed with the help of a fellow metal club member. Sorry, Mj7. but your gonna have to duke it out with Nesquik for your whole "2 should be this and 3 should be this" argument.

Edit: I'm off to bed. If by the time I get up no one has anything to say then this is the list that's going up.

Me liking Tomhet more than their prison era/debut makes me not a fan?

You making a comment that made it seem as though you didn't like Burzum makes you seem like not a Burzum fan.

And don't use the facepalm smiley. You're entire existence is facepalm worthy.

As you can see, JA, I was also for moving DSEV up. I have nothing against it's current position.

Drop My Journey to the Stars by a few spots and list is way to go (MJTTS before KttG is just bad; as I said earlier - brc songs choice for top 5 was perfect).

Because being a presumptuous retard served you so well last time. It must be wonderful being a definitive metal elitist and forcing yourself to tolerate shitty bands all day to make lists that would be outdone by the likes of Vh1. I wish i could have your life. In short, get the hell over yourself, you pathetic glass house dwelling person.

1. Jesu Dod (Filosofem)
2. Dunkelheit (Filosofem)
3. Det Som Engtat Var (Hvis Lyset Tar Oss)
4. Lost Wisdom (Det Som Engtat Var)
5. Key To The Gate (Det Som Engtat Var)
6. Hvis Lyset tar Oss (Hvis Lyset Tar Oss)
7. My Journey to the Stars (Burzum)
8. War (Burzum)
9. Erblicket Die Tochter Des Firmaments (Filosofem)
10. Ea, Lord of the Depths (Burzum)

I never thought I'd see the day when Nesquik would be called an elitist.

if there are no comments by 3 that list is going up.

There's no reason the list can't be edited after it's posted.
Take Sonata Arctica's for example, Don't Say A Word should be top 5 but it isn't even in the top 10.

Someone called me a rap elitist a while back, so there's that. It was probably this same idiot.